Real Color Rescue Cases

Real soaps sent to Color Rescue, what went wrong, and how to fix it. Every case here is shared with the maker’s permission.

Colors not turning out the way you planned? Send us a photo and we'll tell you what happened and how to fix it.

Send us your soap

Color cases

  • Photo coming soon
    Sample
    • White isn't white

    White layer came out ivory instead of white

    Cold process soap

    Colors used

    No white colorant

    What happened

    Soap made without a whitener takes on the color of its oils and fragrance, which is usually ivory or cream. Gel phase can also deepen the color.

    What to change

    Add titanium dioxide for a bright white, dispersed in a little oil first so it doesn't leave white specks. Light-colored oils and a fragrance without vanillin help keep it white.

    Try
  • Photo coming soon
    Sample
    • Red turned orange or brown

    Red turned orange a few days after cutting

    Cold process soap

    Colors used

    A craft-store red mica

    What happened

    Fresh cold process soap is strongly alkaline. Many red micas and lakes can't hold their color at that pH, so the red shifts toward orange or brick as the soap saponifies. It often looks fine at pour and changes over the first few days.

    What to change

    Use a red that has been tested in cold process soap and keep the amount up so the color stays saturated. Mix it into a little oil first so it disperses without specks.

    Try
  • Photo coming soon
    Sample
    • Blue turned green or brown
    • Turned tan or brown

    Blue swirl turned green in a vanilla-scented soap

    Cold process soap

    Colors used

    A blue mica

    What happened

    The blue held up fine. The fragrance contains vanillin, which slowly turns soap tan to brown as it cures. Blue on top of that tan reads as green.

    What to change

    Check the fragrance page for its vanillin content before you pick colors. For a true blue, choose a fragrance with little or no vanillin, or plan the design around a brown base and keep the blue in the parts that won't discolor.

We only show cases the maker chose to make public, with a first name or initials. Want your soap taken down? Contact us and we'll remove it.

Learn more

See a problem or have an idea?

Help us make this better. These tools are new, and we're still fine-tuning them. If something looks off, like a number that doesn't add up, a missing product or a confusing step, email us at our contact page and we'll fix it. Have an idea, or a tool you'd like us to make? We'd love to hear that too!

These tools are new. Tell us what's off, or what you'd like us to make:
Email us